Stopping The Backdoor Draft: Vermont Town Meetings Decide To "End the War, Bring the Guard Home" Apr 1, 2005 – By Ellen Kaye & Joseph Gainza
During the direct democracy ritual of Vermont's Town Meetings, on March 1,
2005, 52 of the 60 towns which discussed the question approved resolutions
opposing the use of Vermont's National Guard in Iraq. Annual town meetings
are the forum in which town budgets are approved or voted down, where members
decide whether to spend money on a new snow plow, a new teaching position, or
funding for the local battered women's shelter. This year, they were also the
place where residents of 60 towns had the opportunity to engage in dialogue
about the Iraq invasion, occupation, and Vermont's role in it.
The resolutions described how the US launched this war -- the deceptions, the
disrespect for international opinion, the utter lack of a national emergency
-- establishing a baseline of basic facts necessary in order to spur
meaningful local, and we hope national, dialogue. According to Army Times,
forty percent of US soldiers in Iraq are members of the National Guard and
Reserves, so fostering a debate about the Guard's role is critical.
The resolutions called for three actions to be taken: the Vermont Legislature
is asked to assess the impact of deployment of the National Guard on
readiness to handle in-state emergencies and, more broadly, the impact on
families, communities, employers and the very fabric of life in Vermont;
Vermont's congressional delegation is called on to work toward restoring
state powers over Guard deployments in cases of "wars of choice;" the final
portion calls on the President to withdraw US forces from Iraq, consistent
with the mandate of international humanitarian law. The voters of Burlington
passed a resolution that called for troops to be withdrawn now.
International humanitarian law requires an occupying power to restore the
health and welfare of the residents of the occupied state. The mention of
this body of law has led some to think that the resolution advocated for a
delay in the withdrawal of US troops from Iraq. Instead, it was intended to
be a reminder of the US obligation to rebuild a country devastated by
dictatorship, wars, sanctions, and a catastrophic occupation. Under
international law, an occupying power is obligated to pay to rebuild the
Iraqi infrastructure and provide medical care, adequate food, education,
housing and other services to the Iraqi people. Instead, the US is
privatizing Iraq in order to enrich US corporations such as Haliburton.
"Our resolutions began with those near to us and ended with the recognition
that every life taken in war is a tragedy, every war a failure of the human
spirit," said Ben Scotch, the original author of the resolution and a leader
of the town meeting campaign. The Vermont Network on Iraq War Resolutions
consists of individuals from many communities across Vermont, and
organizations such as The American Friends Service Committee, The Green
Mountain Veterans for Peace, the Women's International League for Peace and
Freedom, and the Vermont Chapter of Military Families Speak Out (MFSO).
Scores of individuals worked throughout the state to get the resolution on
the town "warning" (the agenda of articles to be voted on at Town Meeting),
collecting signatures from at least 5% of the voters in their town. The
convergence of traditional peace activists with veterans and military family
members demonstrates that there is no contradiction between supporting
soldiers and opposing the war.
The Vermont chapter of MFSO joined this effort with the recognition that it
is military families and veterans who have the moral credibility to
successfully communicate the reality on the ground in Iraq and the
disillusionment that families and soldiers are feeling. "Our soldiers are not
nameless and faceless, they are our family members, our neighbors, our
coworkers, our first responders," says Nancy Brown, whose son was until
recently stationed near Baghdad. Brown is the founder of the Vermont Chapter
of MFSO. MFSO members helped expose how unfairly our troops, particularly the
National Guard, have been treated, with less than adequate training and, in
many cases, insufficient equipment.
In order to prepare for the Town Meetings, organizers throughout the state
met with local fire departments, VFW posts, merchants, family members of
deployed soldiers, and town meeting moderators to discuss the resolution and
enlist support. A one-minute radio spot about the resolution, written by Bob
Bady and Ellen Kaye, the originators of the campaign, and recorded by MFSO
member Sherry Prindall, the mother of a deployed National Guardsman, aired on
several commercial stations throughout Vermont. We believed that even if the
resolution did not pass, this kind of outreach was worth the effort.
The strategy to hold our lawmakers' feet to the fire for their inertia on
this war is deliberate. We want to pressure Congress and other elected
officials to cut the purse strings for military operations in Iraq and bring
the troops home.
The country is paying attention. At the United for Peace and Justice
Coalition assembly in St. Louis, Missouri in February, delegates voted
unanimously for a proposal to make a National Guard Campaign based on the
Vermont model a key part of its program of action. The Governor of Montana is
charging that deployments threaten his state's ability to fight fires during
the upcoming fire season. And Virginia's governor, in a segment of Nightline
focusing on our campaign, criticized the use of the Guard in Iraq.
The Vermont Town Meeting campaign has demonstrated that when people have an
opportunity to discuss foreign policy issues face to face, we will, in
overwhelming numbers, call on the national government to behave as a
responsible member of the world community. It is by strengthening and
broadening such grassroots organizing and dialogue that citizens will begin
to reassert their sovereign right, and obligation, to shape government
policies.
Ellen Kaye is a Brattleboro, VT peace and justice organizer. Joseph
Gainza is the coordinator of AFSC's Vermont Program. To learn more about how
to build on the efforts in Vermont in your community, please see
www.iraqresolution.org and www.afscvt.org, 73 Main St., Box 19, Montpelier,
VT, 05602-2944, 802/229-2340. Originally posted in the April 2005 edition of
the American Friends Service Committee e-journal, Peacework. May be viewed by
clicking here.